Showing posts with label Mark Cuban. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Mark Cuban. Show all posts

Sunday, July 19, 2009

Insider Trading: Three Cases

1. SEC v. Mark Cuban

On Friday, July 17, 2009, Judge Sidney Fitzwater, of the US District Court, Northern District, Texas, in Dallas, ruled in Favor of Mark Cuban, dismissing a lawsuit that the SEC had brought against him. Fitzwater found that the SEC had failed to state a claim on which relief could be grantred.

It did so without prejudice, i.e. the SEC may replead.

The case involved Cuban's knowledge of a forthcoming PIPE -- a private investment in public equity. When all other things are equal, a PIPE will cause a reduction in a stock's price, simply because it increases the supply of that company's stock in the marketplace. Without some corresponding increase in the demand for it, the price should fall.

Cuban was an investor in the company in question but he was not an "insider" to it in the strictest sense -- he was not a board member, officer, etc. On the SEC's theory, he was a fiduciary, and the insider trading was thus a breach of a fiduciary responsibility, i.e. his agreement to keep confidential the information that an issuer's CEO provided to him about a forthcoming PIPE.

But the agreement to keep the information confidential that the SEC alleges does not amount, the court said, to an agreement to refrain from a sale of stock. A sale may hint, to those who learn of it, that the seller has just received some information, but it is hardly a clearcut case of communication. "The complaint asserts no facts that reasonably suggest that the CEO intended to obtaion from Cuban an agreement to refrain from trading on the information as opposed to an agreement merely to keep it confidential," the court said.

2. US v. Ralph Cioffi

Cioffi, who is a criminal defendant in the case arising from the failure of two Bear stearns affiliated hedge funds in 2007, has not been so fortunate as Cuban. His trial judge has rejected his motion to dismiss.

In New York, on Tuesday, July 14, Judge Frederic Block refused to dismiss the criminal case against him that arose because Cioffi transferred a portion of his own holdings out of one of these funds without telling investors. In contrast to Fitzwater, Block has not prepared a written opinion giving us the reasons for this decision. But hsi situation isinherently different from that of Cuban's, and as I've noted here before, I thought the motion to dismiss was a matter of slicing the Oscar Meyer pretty thin.

It is still a rum business -- prosecuting "insider trading," at all. But thinking within the box of the law as now exists, Cioffi's position is much worse than that of Cuban's so the difference results of their motions was to be expected.

3. SEC v. Anthony Perez et al. This is a new one. The SEC has charged 5 individuals with insider trading on the ground that they learned that Liberty Mutual was about to announce a bid for Safeway Corp., and acted naturally, buying Safeway themselves.

There are actually three separate complaints, because this information leaked out at least that many times. In two of the three complaints arising out of the safeway bid, a tippee as well as the tipper are named.

The first-named defendant of one of these three complaints, Perez, acquired this information through his work at Goldman Sachs. His tippee? His brother. Ach! the government is now criminalizing brotherly love!

It is also enabling Goldman conspiracy theories. Personally, I much prefer Cerberus conspiracy theories, but Cerberus seems to have had nothing to do with Safeway.

Wednesday, February 25, 2009

Three brief items

1. Delaware state bar discussing corporate law change

The Delaware State Bar Ass'n has under consideration a proposal to amend the famously-influential Delaware General Corporate Law. If the bar association approves of them, the changes will be submitted to the General Assembly.

The proposed amendments include the creation of two new DGCL sections, Sections 112 and 113, that would (I quote a memo available through the website of Schulte Roth & Zabel) "greatly increase access to a corporation's proxy statement and the right to reimbursement for nominating directors to the corporation's board."

2. The Mark Cuban case

Mark Cuban is the defendant in an insider-trading complaint brought by the SEC in the US district court, northern district of Texas last fall. The SEC's theory of the case pushes at the outer boundaries of what had been considered 'insider trading,' or even 'tippee' status. That's enough reason to send a cheer or two his way.

I discussed the case when it was filed and won't repeat myself unduly.

Instead, I'll simply note that the judge hearing the matter, Sidney Fitzwater, has signed a scheduling order.

The parties have until July 1, 2009 to join other parties.

The party with the burden of proof on a given issue has until September 1 to designate its expertwitnesses, and the other party has until November 1 to designate its rebuttal expert witness.

They have until March 1, 2010 to file their motions for summary judgment.

After all that is disposed of, if nobody gets a summary judgment, the judge will consider the question of a date for trial.

3. Rambus antitrust case

The U.S. Supreme Court, on Monday, rejected a request by the FTC to review an appeals court ruling in favor of Rambus Inc. and against FTC's antitrust allegations. This should put an end to the controversy, underwy for seven years now, about whether Rambus, the owner of the patents to certain memory chips, had improperly manipulatred an industry standards setting group with anti-competitive intent.

The standards setting group was known as the Joint Electron Device Engineering Council (or JEDEC), and the allegation was in essence that Rambus' participation in the deliberations of JEDEC was that of a classic "mole." JEDEC was trying to enable its members to avoid patent hold-ups, and enable members of the industry to move ahead with common standards and without a lot of litigation. Rambus supposedly hid information about its own plans to patent certain technologies, so that in time it could say "aha!" to firms that had acted in the belief they could rely upon JEDEC standards.

In April 2008 the appeals court sided with Rambus, not because it rejected the general view that anti-competitive conduct could take that form but because the FTC had failed to show that Rambus's behavior gave it unlawful monopoly power.

Wednesday, November 19, 2008

A few words about Mark Cuban

I can't say I've admired Mark Cuban in recent years. His public persona is that of the standard-issue billionaire big-mouth, a real-like Tony Stark without the titanium suit, and the ideas behind Cuban's "Sharesleuth" project seem to me entirely misguided.

Gary Weiss explained the problems with Sharesleuth welll in several items posted on his blog in 2007, when that project (supposedly a new model for finance journalism) was at its peak. I'll just link you to one of those items, thereby taking that task off my own shoulders.

Instead I'll say this: unimpressed though I am with Cuban, I suspect he is in the right in his latest fight. The SEC has chosen him as its newest target for its intermittent anti-insider campaign.

I've never been impressed with the idea that punishing insider trading makes sense. Some deterrent for breaches of fiduciary duty is appropriate of course, but that's rather hard to find here.

So I'm rooting for Cuban. Fight the power, MC!

Joe Nocera’s recent book, Good Guys & Bad Guys, makes a related point. It’s in a reprinting of a story Mr. Nocera wrote for GQ in December 1992, concerning Drexel Burnham and Michael Milken.

For the record, Mr. Nocera occupies a ‘moderate’ position on the spectrum of reactions to Mr. Milken [who was in prison when the story was first written]: Nocera argues that the infamous financier was guilty of some crimes, but not of the worst of those of which he was accused, and that his sentence was excessive.

But that isn't what intrigued me about the article. The passage I have in mind quoed an unnamed associate of Milken's saying: “”When a Drexel salesman heard that the corporate-finance department was buying a stock – for what reason he didn’t know – and then advised a client wanting to sell that same stock that he might be better holding on to it, was that an example of insider trading? Or was it something more innocent?”

Good question. Indeed, it’s a better question than Mr. Nocera (who soon drops the query) may understand. There is nothing extraordinary about such an instance, and since given existing law and prosecutorial practices there is no good answer to that question, then the courts and prosecutors who punish insider trading are in effect telling traders, brokers, bond salesmen, etc. that they have to drive 55 miles per hour or below – and that they can’t use a speedometer, because none are available.

That’s wrong.

Personally, when I use the phrase “free markets,” I don’t mean the word “free” as an adjective. I mean it as a verb. Let’s free markets.